In the last few weeks, Bob Pettit and Cliff Hagan have passed away and that got me to thinking about their careers and that of the St. Louis Hawks of the 1950s and 1960s. There is not a ton written about these squads, but most basketball history fans know the basics, which are ably detailed in Terry Pluto’s “Tall Tales”:
-In 1954-55, Pettit struggled as a rookie at center. He took off instantly when coach Red Holzman moved him to power forward. From there, Pettit became an insta-star and is widely hailed as the best forward in the NBA before Elgin Baylor emerged. Pettit won the first ever NBA MVP in 1955-56 (and also won a second MVP in 1958-59).
-The Hawks traded the draft rights to Bill Russell for the rights to Hagan (whom the Celtics had drafted in 1953 but was still serving in the military and had yet to play in the NBA) and Ed Macauley. Despite trading the best player of his generation, the Hawks, at least, got some value in Hagan and Macauley, both of whom would later make the Hall of Fame. Hagan, who was 6’4, also had early struggles. He started out as a guard before moving to forward, where he became a six-time All-Star.
-St. Louis played Boston in the Finals four times in five years from 1956-57 through 1960-61. The first matchup was in 1956-57 when the Hawks played the Celtics and rookie Russell. The wild series featured Red Auerbach punching Hawks owner Ben Kerner. It went seven games and, with the Hawks down two points on the final possession, Alex Hannum inbounded the ball from his own baseline and threw a long lob that he intentionally bounced off the other backboard to Pettit, who caught the carom but missed an open shot to tie the game (according to Tall Tales, Pettit said “I caught the ball in midair and shot it before I came down. The ball rolled around the rim and came out. Really, as crazy as it sounds, I should have made the shot. Alex’s pass was perfect.”). The 1957-58 Hawks are the only team to beat the Bill Russell Celtics in an NBA Finals, thanks to Pettit’s 50-point clincher (yes, Russell was playing with a bad foot/ankle injury).
-The Hawks had a few other star-level players. From 1956-57 through 1958-59, Slater Martin was the Hawks’ All-Star point guard (he was in his early 30s and not quite at his peak but was still effective). In 1960, the Hawks drafted Lenny Wilkens sixth overall and he would make four All-Star games in St. Louis (and nine in his career). Both point guards would make the Hall of Fame.
Having touched on the basics, I thought we could dig a little deeper and see what other facts and/or stats we can glean that are not readily known in our usual FAQ-style.
Forget the numbers, are there any good Pettit stories?
Unlike many early NBA stars, Pettit has few memorable stories. Some of this may be due to the less probing sports journalism of the 1950s. I did a deep dive into pre-1970 articles to see if we could get something interesting and the search was not that fruitful. The earliest features on Pettit mostly note that he was a polite and amiable and hardworking.
A 1955 Sporting News article wrote about his work ethic and noted that: “[o]n the personal side, Pettit is one of the most polite and considerate young men one might encounter. He also has a sound business head and the off-season helps his father with insurance and real estate in Baton Rouge.”
A 1957 Sport article had similar bromides: “[i]n the off-season, Bob lives at home with his mother and father, who are in the real estate business.
Bob is an only child and the family ties are very close. His parents come to St. Louis to see him play whenever possible, and last year they spent Christmas with him in New York.” The article did offer a small peek to Pettit’s intensity: “[h]e is a severe competitor who demands perfection in himself. Once, in a game against Rochester last year, he scored the first two baskets of the game, then couldn’t hit for another one all night. That was a low point in his career.”
The Complete Sports’ 1964-65 Basketball Annual did a feature on Pettit that gave a bit more info, but also noted that he’s far from flashy: “[d]on’t be fooled by the silent, robot-like efficiency of Bob Pettit, however. The man destined to become the National Basketball Association’s first 20,000-point scorer willed himself to greatness.“ The article did provide the first sense of personality, recounting him jawing with former teammate Clyde Lovellette: “Big Clyde was sitting on the bench at Boston Garden last year and giving Pettit a verbal going over in a good-natured way while the game was in progress. Finally, as Pettit stepped to the free-throw line, he turned a mock scowl in Lovellette’s direction and said: ‘Please don’t speak to the players.’”
The first legitimately entertaining story I could find about Pettit came from George Vecsey’s “Pro Basketball Champions,” where coach Red Holzman tells a rookie Pettit to get tougher and that he must deck the next player who screws with him: “Early in the second half, one of the Lakers clipped Pettit with an elbow. Pettit suddenly remembered his coach’s warning. So he looked around for somebody small—maybe even Slater Martin, who was only five-foot-ten. But Martin ducked and Pettit’s fist landed smack in the chest of big Vern Mikkelsen. The punch didn’t budge Mikkelsen. He just stood there glaring at Pettit. The rookie didn’t know what to do. So he said the first thing that came to his mind: ‘Please excuse me, Mr. Mikkelsen.’”
There you have it, I guess the 1950s puff pieces were essentially correct. Pettit was a polite and hardworking dude.
Some Pettit v. Russell & Wilt: stories & stats
A. Rookie Russell and rookie Wilt moments against Pettit
So, the record is clear that Pettit wasn’t exactly Mr. Excitement, but I figured there had to be more details on what it was like to play against Pettit day-to-day. I found some stories in more modern books that provided some interesting details of Pettit interactions with the legends of his era.
John Taylor’s 2005 “The Rivalry,” which focused on Wilt and Russell, gives some more insight with anecdotes about Pettit and these two stars as rookies. The first story comes out of Russell’s first NBA game, on December 22, 1956, against the Hawks, and Red Auerbach wanted Russell to guard Pettit. Taylor described Pettit as follows: “Pettit was strong and fast. He could outrebound much taller men as well, setting up the Hawks’ fast break, and he kept his team fired up by moving tirelessly up and down the court. Auerbach knew Pettit would get away from Russell and make him look bad by scoring, but he saw that as inevitable. The only way Russell would learn to play against men such as Pettit was by playing them.”
How did Russell do against Pettit? “After his first quarter, Russell was also exhausted by the pace of the game, the sheer drain of running after Pettit, who never seemed to slow, much less stop. He was astonished that Pettit could keep it up. ‘Doesn’t this guy ever get tired?’ he asked his veteran teammate Arnie Risen. ‘Sure, he gets tired,‘ Risen said, ‘but he doesn’t look tired.’” Pettit would end up with 28 points on 10-19 shooting and 13 boards, while Russ had 6 points on 3-11 shooting and 16 rebounds in only 21 minutes. Boston would win 95-93 and outscore the Hawks 31-21 in the fourth quarter.
As for Wilt, he was known for his ability to take being continually hacked without retaliating. There are a few notable exceptions like when he went after Sam Jones, who fended Wilt off with a stool, and when he knocked out Clyde Lovellette for being exceedingly annoying. In fact, Pettit was, perhaps, the first NBA player to tick off Wilt enough to hit back. Taylor gives the details on this too: “during the regular season, in a game against the Hawks, Chamberlain finally snapped. Feeling that he was being too closely guarded by Bob Pettit, [Wilt] let fly with an elbow to Pettit’s face, and the Hawks forward had to leave the game to receive two stitches.”
B. Did Russell have beef with Pettit?
There has been plenty of speculation that Pettit and Russell were not friendly because Pettit might’ve shared the outlook of someone who came of age in the South during the 1940s and 1950s. Pettit was literally named after Robert E. Lee and played in St. Louis, which was much slower to integrate the teams. On top of that, two early Black players, Sihugo Green and Cleo Hill, had rough stays with the team.
No matter what Pettit’s views on race were in the 1950s, there is no evidence that Russell had any resentment toward him. In 1965, Sport magazine quoted Russell’s view on Pettit: “There’s not a greater competitor in sports today than Bob Pettit. He made ‘second effort’ a part of the sports vocabulary.”
In 2014, Russell gave an interview that also showed that he and Pettit had deep respect for each other: “One of my favorite memories, and I’ve told this story many times before, is that my grandfather had never seen me play basketball. So my father and my grandfather go to the game, and they’re watching me play. During the game, [St. Louis Hawks superstar] Bob Pettit says to my grandfather, ‘It’s nice to meet you, Mr. Russell.’ On the way back to Monroe after the game, my grandfather says to my father, ‘Something happened to me today that’s never happened before.’ My father said, ‘What’s that?’ And my grandfather said, ‘I’m ninety-one years old, and that’s the first time in my life that a white man has called me Mister.’” In that same interview, Russ, again, complimented Pettit’s game: “Bob made ‘second effort’ a part of the sports vocabulary. He kept coming at you more than any man in the game. He was always battling for position, fighting you off the boards. And he was always great under pressure.”
Russ was not the type to same something nice about someone he actually didn’t like. It’s fair to say that he had no beef with Pettit.
C. Stats v. Wilt & Russ
This is just a quick run on how Pettit did versus Russell and Wilt:
-Per Basketball-Reference.com, Pettit went 21-47 against Russell and 10-13 in the playoffs. Pettit exceeded his averages in the regular season against Russ in the regular season (28.7 ppg on .440 FG%, 17.8 rpg) and in the playoffs (28.9 ppg on .429 FG%, 16.4 rpg). Russell exceeded his averages as well. We took a closer look at their playoff matchups below.
-Per Basketball-Reference.com, Pettit went 33-23 against Wilt and had 28 ppg on .443 FG%, and 18 rpg (which all exceeded his career averages), though Wilt had 37 ppg on .532 FG%, and 23 rpg (which also exceeded his own career averages). Wilt beat Pettit in their one playoff series matchup, the 1963-64 Western Division Finals. Wilt had 38.6 ppg on .559 FG%, while Pettit had only 21.1 ppg on .421 FG%.
Was there ever a chance that the Hawks would’ve kept Russell to play with Pettit?
It’s often wondered whether the Hawks had any chance of keeping Russell and not trading him. The answer seems to be a clear no. The reason why it wasn’t happening, though, is subject to some dispute. Norm Drucker said in Tall Tales that “[i]n 1956, St. Louis was an anti-Black city. The Black players who played there from other teams—the fans called them such names…..I don’t know if Ben Kerner was willing to bring a Black player into that environment, although I do know that Ben himself got along very well with his Black players in the 1960s.”
Kerner, for his part, said in Tall Tales that the issue was cost: “I knew I couldn’t afford Russell. I heard that he had turned down $50,000 from the Globetrotters. I heard he wanted $25,000 or $50,000—it didn’t matter because to me, it may as well have been a million. We didn’t have the money.”
In “The Rivalry,” John Taylor gave a slightly different spin: “[s]ince Kerner already had, in the 6’9 Pettit, one of the biggest men and best rebounders in the league, he was not seriously considering drafting Bill Russell. An unknown and unproven rookie from California, he would hardly be an immediate box-office draw in St. Louis. And if Russell missed the first six weeks of the season due to the Olympics, he might arrive too late to help the team break out in a crucial year. Kerner needed someone who could galvanize the gate on opening night.”
Macauley was a St. Louis native, so presumably he could help at the gate. All sources agree that the trade was to be Macauley for Russ and that Kerner, at the last minute, demanded the rights to Hagan as well. Going back to Tall Tales, Kerner said “’Red, I need bodies. Macauley is not enough. It’s Hagan and Macauley or no deal.’” Auerbach’s response: “Kerner played it cute…I loved players from Kentucky and knew Hagan would be good, but Kerner stuck to the demand.”
According to Taylor, Russell was paid $24,000 as a rookie (slightly less than established star Bob Cousy’s $25,000). Kerner paid Pettit (who was also a huge star) $9,000. We don’t have exact salaries for Macauley and Hagan, but we can make reasonable estimates. Macauley mentioned he was making about $17,500 in Tall Tales. As for Hagan, we know that most rookies started at $5,000 to $7,000 in that time period. In other words, Kerner got two players for the price of Russell, which is consistent with Kerner’s explanation for the trade. I tend to believe the cost was the most significant factor. As for the racial climate, it probably didn’t help, but if Kerner had any inkling how good Russell was going to be, he would’ve pushed the envelope.
How do Pettit’s Hawks rank against their peers?
To assess how good the Hawks were, let’s focus on the nine-year period that Russell Celtics overlapped with Pettit (1956-57 through 1964-65). First, here are the top 30 teams of that period by SRS:
| Rk | Season | Team | SRS | G | W | L | W/L% |
| 1 | 1961-62 | BOS | 8.25 | 80 | 60 | 20 | 0.750 |
| 2 | 1959-60 | BOS | 7.62 | 75 | 59 | 16 | 0.787 |
| 3 | 1964-65 | BOS | 7.46 | 80 | 62 | 18 | 0.775 |
| 4 | 1963-64 | BOS | 6.93 | 80 | 59 | 21 | 0.738 |
| 5 | 1962-63 | BOS | 6.38 | 80 | 58 | 22 | 0.725 |
| 6 | 1958-59 | BOS | 5.84 | 72 | 52 | 20 | 0.722 |
| 7 | 1957-58 | BOS | 5.02 | 72 | 49 | 23 | 0.681 |
| 8 | 1960-61 | BOS | 4.94 | 79 | 57 | 22 | 0.722 |
| 9 | 1956-57 | BOS | 4.78 | 72 | 44 | 28 | 0.611 |
| 10 | 1963-64 | CIN | 4.43 | 80 | 55 | 25 | 0.688 |
| 11 | 1963-64 | SFW | 4.41 | 80 | 48 | 32 | 0.600 |
| 12 | 1958-59 | SYR | 3.74 | 72 | 35 | 37 | 0.486 |
| 13 | 1962-63 | SYR | 3.40 | 80 | 48 | 32 | 0.600 |
| 14 | 1960-61 | STL | 2.99 | 79 | 51 | 28 | 0.646 |
| 15 | 1958-59 | STL | 2.89 | 72 | 49 | 23 | 0.681 |
| 16 | 1959-60 | PHW | 2.77 | 75 | 49 | 26 | 0.653 |
| 17 | 1959-60 | SYR | 2.77 | 75 | 45 | 30 | 0.600 |
| 18 | 1964-65 | STL | 2.68 | 80 | 45 | 35 | 0.563 |
| 19 | 1962-63 | LAL | 2.67 | 80 | 53 | 27 | 0.663 |
| 20 | 1961-62 | PHW | 2.63 | 80 | 49 | 31 | 0.613 |
| 21 | 1961-62 | SYR | 2.24 | 80 | 41 | 39 | 0.513 |
| 22 | 1957-58 | SYR | 2.18 | 72 | 41 | 31 | 0.569 |
| 23 | 1964-65 | CIN | 2.04 | 80 | 48 | 32 | 0.600 |
| 24 | 1960-61 | SYR | 1.93 | 79 | 38 | 41 | 0.481 |
| 25 | 1961-62 | LAL | 1.80 | 80 | 54 | 26 | 0.675 |
| 26 | 1959-60 | STL | 1.77 | 75 | 46 | 29 | 0.613 |
| 27 | 1964-65 | LAL | 1.70 | 80 | 49 | 31 | 0.613 |
| 28 | 1956-57 | PHW | 1.54 | 72 | 37 | 35 | 0.514 |
| 29 | 1963-64 | STL | 1.39 | 80 | 46 | 34 | 0.575 |
| 30 | 1962-63 | STL | 1.38 | 80 | 48 | 32 | 0.600 |
First thing we notice is that the team stats very much reflect the Celtics’ absolute dominance. Of the nine season window of Pettit’s career where he overlapped with the Russell Celtics, the top nine SRS all belong to the Celtics by a healthy margin. The 1956-57 Celtics were had a slimmer margin because it was missing Russell for the first 24 games (in fact, Boston’s SRS without Russ was about 3.87 and 5.23 with him). Removing Boston from the equation, the Hawks had several good teams but none with SRS exceeding 2.99. It is true that SRS is a bit deceiving when applied to an eight-team league (the league expanded to nine teams in 1961-62). The low non-Celtic SRS numbers say less about the other teams being unusually bad than about one historically strong team in a small league.
Another method to assess whether the Hawks were the clear number two team in the NBA is surveying how each team did against the mighty Celtics over that same time period. Here are their regular season stats against Boston:
| Team | Wins | Losses | Win% | Point Diff. |
| Nationals | 40 | 68 | 0.370 | -4.3 |
| Hawks | 26 | 56 | 0.317 | -5.5 |
| Warriors | 32 | 69 | 0.317 | -4.7 |
| Knicks | 30 | 78 | 0.278 | -8.1 |
| Royals | 23 | 65 | 0.261 | -6.8 |
| Lakers | 21 | 62 | 0.253 | -8.2 |
| Bullets | 7 | 33 | 0.175 | -11.7 |
| Pistons | 11 | 69 | 0.138 | -11.4 |
The Hawks were near the top of the list of Celtic opposition in the regular season but the Warriors and Nats/76ers rate slightly better. Now let’s look at how the group did against Boston in the playoffs:
| Team | Wins | Losses | Win% | Point Diff. |
| Hawks | 11 | 14 | 0.440 | -7.2 |
| Royals | 4 | 8 | 0.333 | -6.8 |
| Nationals | 7 | 15 | 0.318 | -7.0 |
| Warriors | 7 | 16 | 0.304 | -5.0 |
| Lakers | 6 | 16 | 0.273 | -5.5 |
The Hawks had the most success in terms of wins, but their -7.2 ppg margin is much worse than that of the Warriors (-5.0) and Lakers (-5.5). This success is not reflected in the point-differential. Slicing it a little thinner, let’s look at the Hawks’ per series point-differential against the Celtics in their Finals matchups:
1956-57: Boston win 4-3 (-5.1 ppg differential): The Hawks won three games by 2 ppg each time but lost four games by an average of 10.5 ppg
1957-58: St. Louis win 4-2 (-4.5 ppg differential): The Hawks won four games by 2 ppg each time but lost two games by an average of 17.5 ppg
1959-60: Boston win 4-3 (-7.8 ppg differential): The Hawks won three games by 7.7 ppg and (finally) beat the Celtics by more than three points in a playoff game, but lost four games by an average of 19.5 ppg
1960-61: Boston win 4-1 (-12.4 ppg differential): The Hawks won their sole game by four points but Boston won by margins of +34, +8, +15, and +9
The interesting question: was the Hawks’ ability to hang tight in three of these Finals a function of luck or some strategic skill? The Hawks were 8-1 in games decided by three points or fewer and the one close game they did lose decided the 1956-57 Finals. The Hawks were 3-13 in all other Finals games against Boston. Viewed another way, St. Louis was 7-4 at home (-2.0 ppg differential) and 4-10 at Boston (-11.3 ppg differential). I’d guess there was a little luck involved but that St. Louis homecourt advantage may have made a big difference in close games as well.
How good was Pettit relative to peers?
He was quite good and immediately too. As a rookie, Pettit got better every month and, by the end of the season, he had averaged 20.4 ppg (4th in the NBA) and 13.8 rpg (2nd in the NBA) and his advanced stats were also elite: 24.9 PER (2nd in the NBA) and 10.7 WS (4th in the NBA). In fact, Pettit had, by far, the best season by a 22-year-old in BAA/NBA history up to that point. To give a little context, the prior highest ppg for a 22-year-old was Joe Graboski’s 13.7 ppg in 1951-52 (Pettit’s teammate Frank Selvy, also 22, had 19 ppg that same season).
He would soon be overtaken by Russell and Wilt but, at the start of the 1955-56 season, Pettit was the clear emerging star in the NBA. The Sporting News did a feature on Pettit in training camp in 1955 that reflected this moment, quoting Hannum as saying about Pettit: “He’s the greatest. Yes, I said the greatest. They simply don’t come any better in all-round play and shotmaking.”
Pettit told The Sporting News that he wasn’t quite fully formed: “Please remember, I’m still learning. We pick up new pointers every game. As I look back on last season, I can see where I made so many mistakes. Our team is young and we’re just beginning to work together. We’ve got a long way to go and I’m only a beginner.”
Pettit’s statement was not false humility. He improved markedly in 1955-56 (25.7 ppg, 16.2 rpg and won his first MVP). From 1955-56 through 1962-63, Pettit scored no fewer than 24.6 ppg and maxed out at 31.1 ppg. He was eclipsed by Russ, Wilt, and arguably others like Elgin, West, and Oscar, but the MVP voters (the players voted in those days and could not vote for their own teammates) certainly held Pettit in high esteem. Here’s how the yearly MVP vote went for Pettit during his career (note that the MVP award was not an official award until 1955-56):
1955-56: Pettit was first with 33 votes (Paul Arizin was second with 21 votes)
1956-57: Pettit (21 votes) was a narrow second to Bob Cousy (23 votes). A rookie Russell somehow got only two votes.
1957-58: Russell won with 33 votes. Pettit was fourth with four votes, behind rivals Dolph Schayes (25 votes) and George Yardley (12 votes).
1958-59: Pettit won with 59 first place votes (this was the first season that the voters could vote for more than just the first place choice). Russell came in a distant second with 10 first place votes.
1959-60: Wilt won MVP as a rookie with 49 first place votes and Russ was second (15 first place votes). Pettit was consensus choice for third place behind the two legends.
1960-61: Russell won with 35 first place votes, but Pettit was second (14 first place votes), ahead of Elgin, Wilt, Oscar, and Cousy.
1961-62: Pettit was sixth in the voting behind Russ, Wilt, Oscar, West, and Baylor.
1962-63: Pettit came in fourth behind Russell (consensus winner), Wilt, and Oscar.
1963-64: Pettit came in fourth behind Oscar (consensus winner), Wilt, and Russ.
1964-65: Pettit’s final season he was an All-Star and second team All-NBA but he didn’t get any MVP votes.
Over that period, Pettit was in the top four in the MVP voting every season except 1961-62 and 1964-65 and made All-NBA first team every year except 1964-65. At the end of his career, Pettit had a credible case for being the third best player ever and the best big forward ever. Here’s how Pettit compared with his non-Wilt and Russ competition:
| Player | Age | From | To | G | MP | PER | TS% | AST% | OWS | DWS | WS | WS/48 |
| Elgin Baylor | 24-30 | 1958-59 | 1964-65 | 493 | 20580 | 24.5 | 0.492 | 15.0 | 44.9 | 25.7 | 70.6 | 0.165 |
| Bob Pettit | 22-32 | 1954-55 | 1964-65 | 792 | 30690 | 25.5 | 0.511 | 11.7 | 91.8 | 44.2 | 136 | 0.213 |
| Oscar Robertson | 22-26 | 1960-61 | 1964-65 | 384 | 17036 | 26.2 | 0.567 | 37.8 | 71.0 | 12.3 | 83.3 | 0.235 |
| Dolph Schayes | 21-35 | 1949-50 | 1963-64 | 996 | 29800 | 22.1 | 0.488 | N/A | 86.3 | 56.1 | 142.4 | 0.192 |
| Jerry West | 22-26 | 1960-61 | 1964-65 | 355 | 14019 | 22.1 | 0.533 | 20.0 | 45.4 | 12.9 | 58.3 | 0.200 |
The numbers are more limited by record-keeping but Pettit crushes most of the competition except for Oscar. At worst, Pettit was the fourth or fifth best player of the Shot Clock Era.
Pettit’s historical ranking
While Pettit is mostly forgotten today, he is still ranked highly in a number of periodic All-Time rankings. These lists are totally subjective, but they do reflect the expert opinions over time and are fun to track. Here’s a sampling:
-In Dave Heeren’s 1990-91 Basketball Abstract, his Tendex formula ranked Pettit as the best forward ever, though he questioned that result based on the limited stats and lower competition. He did rank Pettit as a top ten player. (Heeren did a new Top 75 in 2021 that had Pettit in the top 20).
-Dave Shouler’s 1996 Top 50 book ranked Pettit third among forwards behind Larry Bird and Elgin Baylor (the book did not do overall rankings, only positional rankings) and called him the prototypical power forward.
-Elliott Kalb’s 2003 top 50 book ranked Pettit 11th All-Time and third among forwards behind Bird and Tim Duncan.
-Bill Simmons’ 2009 Book of Basketball ranked Pettit 17th All-Time, fifth among forwards behind Bird, Duncan, John Havlicek, and Baylor.
-The Athletic’s 2024 Top 100 list ranked Pettit 32nd in the voting but John Hollinger’s GOAT Points formula had him 18th overall and seventh at forward behind LeBron, Duncan, Malone, Bird, Durant, and Garnett.
It’s very hard to know how a Pettit from his peak would do today. He wouldn’t be quite the star he was, but he would be good today (Simmons called him a cross between Paul Pierce and Carlos Boozer). I see Pettit’s high-end projection as a Kevin Love-type game with a Karl Malone motor. In any case, Pettit deserves to be remembered as the best player in the NBA behind Wilt & Russ for a few years, and I hope this review gave him a bit more depth for modern fans.